Diocese clarifies official position on gay-rights vote
By Steven G. Vegh Maine's Roman Catholic diocese said Thursday that its neutral stance on the state's gay-rights law does not diminish its strong opposition to discrimination against homosexuals.
Staff Writer
©Copyright 1998 Guy Gannett Communications
In a statement published in The Church World newspaper, the Diocesan Public Policy Committee said: ''The teaching of the Church makes it clear that the fundamental human rights of homosexual persons must be defended.''
The statement, also published in The Church World on Jan. 22, was called a clarification of the diocese's position on the statewide referendum scheduled Feb. 10 on the gay-rights law.
Voters will be asked if they want to overturn legislation approved last spring that bars discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. At least a quarter-million Mainers are Catholic, and some of them may look to the church's position on the issue before voting.
Although the diocese opposes discrimination, it is officially neutral on the ballot question because it believes the new law does not make clear whether the state is condoning homosexual activity.
It also believes that the law is ambiguous about what kinds of religiously affiliated organizations, such as schools and charities, could be exempt from the law.
In its statement, the diocesan committee said, ''there is a need for the protection of people because of past and present acts of discrimination and violence'' based on sexual orientation.
The committee stressed that the church approves of sex only between a man and a woman within marriage. However, the church teaches that homosexual orientation by itself cannot be considered sinful.
The Rev. Paul Cote, who chairs the policy committee, said the diocesan statement was in the making for several months before its publication.
He said the diocese saw the need to make its stance clear last summer, after the gay-rights bill was approved by the Legislature and Gov. Angus King.
''The diocese is not neutral: it supports the human rights of gay individuals in . . . terms of housing, credit, employment and public accommodation,'' Cote said. ''It's just that the current legislation is considered flawed.''
The diocese tried unsuccessfully to amend the bill to ease its concerns.
This month's policy statement did not mollify Rosemary Ananis or Paul Madore, two Maine Catholics with strong feelings about the referendum.
Ananis, of Wells, is the New England regional coordinator for Dignity, the national organization of gay and lesbian Catholics.
''I want the diocese to recognize this referendum is about discrimination and to stand up against it,'' said Ananis. ''Jesus always stood up against injustice, and unless the referendum is defeated, that's what we're up against.''
Madore is deeply involved in the campaign to overturn the gay-rights law. He was an active supporter of an unsuccessful anti-gay-rights referendum in 1995, and helped overturn Lewiston's gay-rights ordinance in 1993.
Madore said he accepts Catholic teaching that says homosexuals deserve the love of God and other Christians.
But he attacked the diocesan policy statement as opening the door to laws that would encourage the spread of homosexuality and what he called sexual depredation of children.
Madore said the statement ignores church teaching, which he said allows discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation in situations involving children.
''To allow something like this to be printed in Church World is an act of violence against children, because they'll fall victim if these laws pass,'' he said.
Supporters of gay-rights law to begin running TV ads
By Peter Pochna
Staff Writer
©Copyright 1998 Guy Gannett Communications
Opponents lack the money to buy commercials to counter the 'Vote No' camp. Maine Won't Discriminate plans to start a television advertising campaign today that will play a critical role in the group's effort to preserve Maine's gay-rights law.
A commercial featuring Gov. Angus King urging a ''no'' vote on the Feb. 10 referendum will start running tonight throughout the state. It will continue to be shown until Election Day.
A second ''vote no'' commercial likely will be added to the campaign in the next few days.
Political analysts say the TV campaign is an important advantage that Maine Won't Discriminate has over its opponents, who have not raised enough money to run many commercials, if any.
Commercials will let gay-rights supporters urge a statewide audience to get to the polls. The group is focusing much of its efforts on voter turnout, because a low turnout is expected to benefit the proponents of a ''yes'' vote to overturn the gay-rights law.
The broad reach of television is particularly important because the two sides have had little time to publicize their views.
The campaign began in November, when King set the referendum date, and has been made even shorter by the ice storms that consumed the attention of most Mainers for much of January.
''Maine does not believe in discrimination,'' said Joe Cooper, a spokesman for Maine Won't Discriminate. ''We just have to make sure people understand the issue and go out and vote.''
King, who will help Maine Won't Discriminate deliver that message, signed the gay-rights bill into law last May after the Legislature passed it.
Paul Madore, a leader of the ''Vote Yes'' campaign, said his side will overcome its disadvantages in fund-raising and advertising.
''We don't have the money, but we have the people,'' Madore said. ''We just have to work that much harder.''
The Portland Press Herald Home Page
Letters to the Editor
The Maine GayNet Archive